What Will Replace Allspice?
There is currently no satisfactory replacement for allspice. Its unique flavor profile cannot be replicated with any singular spice or combination of spices. However, some substitutions that can come close in flavor include a mixture of cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves or a combination of black pepper and cloves. These substitutes may work well in recipes that call for just a small amount of allspice, but for recipes that require a significant amount of allspice, it is best to try and source the real thing.