Is Al Pastor Smoked?

Al Pastor is a beloved Mexican dish that has gained popularity all around the world. A traditional al pastor consists of marinated pork that is roasted on a vertical spit. The tender meat is then sliced and served on tortillas with salsa, onions, and cilantro.

However, there is a long-standing debate about whether al pastor should be smoked or not. Some people argue that smoked al pastor adds an extra layer of flavor and aroma, while others believe that smoking alters the authentic taste of the dish. In this article, we will explore the origins of al pastor, the traditional cooking methods, and whether smoking is a viable option for creating this delicious dish.

Quick Answer
Al Pastor is traditionally prepared by marinating pork in a mixture of spices and pineapple juice and then roasting it on a vertical spit called a trompo. The meat is not smoked during the preparation process.

The History of Al Pastor and Traditional Preparation Methods

Al Pastor, which literally translates to “shepherd’s style,” is a popular Mexican dish typically made with marinated pork that is roasted on a vertical spit called a “trompo.” While it is commonly associated with Mexican cuisine, its roots can be traced back to the Middle East, specifically the shawarma and doner kebab.

Traditionally, al pastor is made by layering thinly sliced pork marinated in a mixture of dried chilies, spices, and pineapple on the spit. As it rotates, the outside layer of meat is shaved off and served on a tortilla with toppings like diced onions, cilantro, and salsa. This preparation method is quite similar to how shawarma and doner kebab are traditionally made, highlighting the Middle Eastern influence on the dish. Today, variations of al pastor can also be made with chicken or beef and cooked in a variety of ways, including on a grill or in an oven.

The Debate Surrounding Smoked Al Pastor

The debate surrounding smoked al pastor centers around the traditional method of cooking this popular Mexican dish. Some argue that al pastor should only be cooked using the vertical spit method, while others believe that smoking the meat adds a unique flavor profile to the dish.

Those in favor of smoked al pastor argue that the smoky flavor and tenderness of the meat is unbeatable. Smoking the meat also allows for the addition of different flavor components such as marination in pineapple juice, spices, and chili peppers. However, traditionalists believe that the vertical spit is the only way to cook al pastor and that the smoking process takes away from the authenticity of the dish. Ultimately, whether or not al pastor should be smoked remains a matter of personal preference.

Regional Variations: Is Smoked Al Pastor More Common in Certain Areas?

Al Pastor is a popular Mexican dish made with spit-grilled pork that’s typically served in tacos. Although the dish is not usually smoked, there are some regional variations where smoked Al Pastor is more common. In general, the dish is prepared by marinating pork with a unique blend of spices and herbs, then cooking it slowly on a grill or spit.

In areas like northern Mexico, some vendors prefer to smoke their Al Pastor for a distinct, smoky flavor. The use of mesquite wood is common in this region, which gives the meat a smoky and slightly sweet taste. However, this style is not as widespread as the traditional non-smoked version, which is still the most typical way of preparing Al Pastor in most parts of Mexico and the United States.

The Pros and Cons of Smoked Al Pastor: Flavor, Texture, and Authenticity

The Pros and Cons of Smoked Al Pastor: Flavor, Texture, and Authenticity

Smoking al pastor can add a unique and delicious flavor to the meat. The smokiness pairs well with the sweetness of the pineapple and the tanginess of the marinade. It can create a mouth-watering experience that is sure to delight any palate. The smoke can also help to tenderize the meat, making it more tender and juicy.

However, some argue that smoking al pastor takes away from its authenticity. Traditional al pastor is cooked on a spit, with an open flame and the meat slowly rotating. The smoke can also alter the texture of the meat, making it tougher and drier. Plus, smoking al pastor can take longer than traditional cooking methods, which may not be practical for some restaurants or home cooks. Ultimately, the decision to smoke al pastor comes down to personal preference and the desired outcome.

Methods for Achieving the Smoky Flavor in Al Pastor Without Smoking

While traditional al pastor involves smoking, there are methods to achieve the smoky flavor without actually smoking the meat. One common method is to use liquid smoke, which can be added to the marinade or baste during cooking. This gives the meat a smoky flavor without the need for a smoker. However, some purists argue that liquid smoke can give an artificial flavor and is not as authentic as smoking the meat.

Another method is to cook the meat in a cast iron skillet or on a griddle over high heat until it develops a charred crust. This imparts a smoky flavor and also mimics the texture and flavors of traditional al pastor. Additionally, using spices such as smoked paprika or chipotle powder in the marinade or rub can give the meat a smoky flavor profile. By using these methods, one can still enjoy the delicious taste of al pastor without the need for a smoker.

Authenticity and Culinary Innovation: How Chefs are Adapting Traditional Al Pastor

In recent years, chefs have been adapting traditional Al Pastor to create new culinary experiences. While some argue that these adaptations may stray from the authenticity of the dish, others see it as a way to showcase the versatility of Al Pastor and keep the dish relevant.

One popular adaptation is the “Al Pastor taco,” which incorporates traditional Al Pastor meat into a taco with non-traditional toppings such as pineapple, salsa, and guacamole. Another adaptation is the “Al Pastor pizza,” which uses the traditional flavors of Al Pastor and incorporates them into a pizza with creative toppings like cilantro, onions, and even pineapple. Despite the adaptations, many chefs still honor the origin of Al Pastor and use traditional cooking methods such as the traditional spinning spit, or trompo, to cook the meat.

The Future of Al Pastor: Predictions for the Role of Smoking in this Popular Mexican Dish

The future of Al Pastor is looking bright, as many culinary experts believe that smoking will continue to play a significant role in this delicious Mexican dish. While Al Pastor traditionally involves marinating pork in a blend of spices and roasting it on a spit, many chefs are experimenting with adding a smoky flavor to this classic dish.

Some experts predict that smoking will become a more common technique for preparing Al Pastor, as it adds depth and complexity to the dish. Whether using a wood-fired grill or a high-quality smoker, smoking can help to infuse the pork with rich, smoky flavors that perfectly complement the dish’s other ingredients. With its growing popularity and versatility, Al Pastor is poised to become even more delicious in the years to come.


Al pastor is a dish that has a long history and a unique flavor. While it originated in Mexico, it has become popular all around the world, with different variations of the dish being created. One of the most debated aspects of al pastor is whether or not it is smoked. While some people believe that traditional al pastor is smoked, others believe it is simply marinated and cooked on a spit.

After researching the history of al pastor and the different cooking methods, it seems that the traditional way of making al pastor does not involve smoking. Instead, the meat is marinated with various spices and seasonings before being placed on a spit and cooked until tender. However, modern adaptations of the dish have incorporated smoking as a way to add extra flavor and depth to the meat. Regardless of whether al pastor is smoked or not, it remains a delicious and beloved dish by many.

Leave a Comment